Username:  Remember me?
Password:




Post new topic Reply to topic  [ 6 posts ] 
Author Message
 Post subject: I feel such contempt for the spineless MPs who betrayed Gary McKinnon...
Post Number:#1  PostPosted: Wed Jul 22, 2009 9:29 pm 
Offline

Joined: 19 April 2008
Posts: 159
Location: South of Hampshire
I feel such contempt for the spineless MPs who betrayed Gary McKinnon, says mother of 'funny, handsome and brilliant' Asperger's son

Daily Mail, 22nd July 2009

Recently, I took my seven-year-old son Henry to the park. It was a gloriously sunny day and the park is in one of those expensive parts of London where the cafe sells only organic sausages and the children are clad head-to-toe in Boden.

Henry was happily playing on the roundabout. He was loving the thrill as it whirled around, gleefully calling out 'Faster! Faster!' as other children pushed with all their might.

But I wasn't smiling. Because I could tell already that one child, a little girl with a mean smirk on her face, had already clocked there was something different about the handsome boy with fair hair who was flapping his hands with excitement. Half under her breath, and to his utter confusion, she started to mimic his giddy shouts and his almost imperceptible lisp.

'You can't talk properly,' she sneered. Henry, instead of ignoring her or insulting her back, asked earnestly and anxiously: 'What aren't I saying properly?' I could have cried for him.

Then she started to kick him. I asked her to stop, and she ignored me. Finally, exasperated, unable to think of a way to get her to desist, Henry grabbed the girl's sunhat from her head and threw it on the grass.

At which point the child's outraged mother came running over, her face contorted in fury, bellowing at him for 'bullying' her darling daughter, who was clearly thrilled at this turn of events.

A 'normal' child would probably have retaliated in a more sophisticated - for which read underhand and malicious - way, but that's not Henry's style. You see, he has Asperger's syndrome, a type of autism, and the same condition as that of Gary McKinnon, the UFO spotter who now faces the terrifying prospect of deportation to a brutal U.S. prison for up to 70 years.

The first time I read about Gary and his mother's desperate fight to save him - assisted by a powerful Daily Mail campaign - I felt a chill of fear for him and his future.

While I see that my son is funny, handsome, loving and affectionate, with a forensic brain - he is also naive, eccentric, and, like Gary, fascinated by computers.

Most dangerously of all, like Gary, his condition means he sometimes combines a compulsive need to follow any mission to its conclusion with an almost complete inability to envisage any negative outcome.

When I heard how Gary so readily confessed to his crimes, and how he continues to chatter happily about his alien conspiracy theories despite all the trouble he is in, I felt slightly sick.

It's hard for people who don't understand Asperger's or live with someone who has it, to realise that what we might regard as wrong might not appear that way to an 'Aspie' - as many like to dub themselves.

In common with many people with Asperger's, Henry has an intense belief in truth and justice. I wouldn't dare fib about my age in his hearing, for example, as he will insist on putting me right at the top of his voice.

If he, like Gary, came to believe that the U.S. government was telling lies about alien invasions, or hiding the truth about a new source of power that could provide free fuel for the poor, he, too, might feel it was his duty to expose the truth.

At times, parenting Henry can be exhausting, stressful and frustrating. He is very emotional, easily upset and stressed by things other children take in their stride, such as his sister climbing into the car first, which can lead to floods of tears. Or his leaving his lunch bag on the school coach, which provokes panic. Large parties can overwhelm him with their noise and chaos, so you might find him pottering about or spinning around, talking to himself and ignoring everyone.

He is prone to misunderstanding other people's intentions, is blind to body language and so might talk to us for hours about one of his pet subjects, oblivious to boredom.

He is stubborn, argumentative, determined, extremely impulsive, and has never met a button or lever he could resist pressing.

He is always the first person in the house to master any new technology, be it my mobile phone, a digital camera or, most recently, the new family TV. The other night he happily sat in bed reading the manual that came with it, and came downstairs the next morning knowing every feature.

But, contrary to the stereotypes, he also adores stories and jokes and has an infectious giggle that has often left me and his father in tears of laughter.

Some adults find him baffling, alien, but others find him instantly captivating. To be honest, sometimes when I see other children being snide and cunning, I realise how much I prefer my own son's straightforward and direct nature.

When Henry was first properly diagnosed at the age of four, I was grief-stricken. I had first realised he was different from his peers when he was slow to meet physical milestones, even though he was clearly very bright.

He didn't sit up independently until he was eight months old, he never crawled and, as time went by, he didn't start charging about like my friends' children of the same age.

At his standard two-year check with a health visitor, while he was speaking fluently, recognising all his letters and colours, and counting, he wasn't remotely interested in performing 'on demand' or co-operating with all the little tasks she set him.

I was used to his independent ways and thought little of it, but it was clearly a red flag for autism.

Most children like to impress adults and do what they are asked. Henry just liked to do what was interesting to him. He also didn't point in the orthodox way by using his index finger. Instead, he'd either not point at all, or use his thumb or third finger if he couldn't make me look at something he wanted to know the name of, or wanted me to fetch. This is another early sign of autism.

There were, however, various indicators that Henry never displayed: he's never lined up anything in rows in his entire life. Neither is he tidy. In fact, he is as chaotic and untidy as I am, and loses everything. His scatty memory doesn't help. Half my life is spent finding things that Henry has mislaid.

He was first diagnosed with dyspraxia, a condition that affects co-ordination - his handwriting is terrible and he cannot ride a bike - and then shortly after with Asperger's syndrome.

The paediatrician was pretty brutal in his manner, and sent us away with a stack of hideously depressing leaflets from the National Autistic Society, full of doom and gloom, and which seemed to suggest our son was some kind of robot who would amount to nothing.

Henry has a younger sister, Cecily, who is four, and they are much like any other siblings. They fight ferociously, are shockingly competitive, make each other laugh, watch hours of telly companionably, and are fiercely loyal to each other.

Henry doesn't like being parted from her, would always prefer her to come with him to parties, and wouldn't dream of getting a bag of sweets and not saving half for his sister. If I encourage him to eat them up, he tells me in no uncertain terms that this would be unfair.

Cecily admires her big brother's cleverness and ability to find her favourite programme on the telly in an instant. And no matter how much they argue, if anyone dares pick on Henry in the park or at a play centre, they soon find they have a tiny blonde spitfire to deal with.

It is impressive to see her squaring up to a much bigger kid, her hands on her hips, eyes blazing, yelling: 'You leave my brother alone!'

Though I hate the terminology of Asperger's 'sufferer', sometimes having Asperger's syndrome does make life hard for those who have it. The statistics on depression, bullying in schools and suicide rates are, frankly, terrifying, though I hope and believe things are changing.

Luckily Henry, unlike Gary McKinnon, was diagnosed early and qualified for special help in the classroom. But though he seems popular, and several little girls in particular adore him, to his sadness and mine, the playdates and parties his classmates' lives revolve around seem to happen for him far less often.

It is isolating for him and for me, and the struggle to get him the provision he needs to do well at school is exhausting, though we are one of the 'lucky' families. Henry has learning support assistants at his state school, without whose help and guidance he would probably sink like a stone in a mainstream classroom.

I have to admit that initially the idea that my beautiful first-born was somehow 'damaged' sent me into a spiral of depression, which I think, looking back, lasted about a year. I was unable to think or speak about his diagnosis without crying. I was so scared for his future.

But now I refuse to think of him - or his Asperger's - like that. The human race owes a huge debt to autism. The autistic mind very often works in ways that are dazzlingly creative and original, and as he grows up, I want Henry to be proud of his Asperger's identity.

Isaac Newton almost certainly had Asperger's, as did Alan Turing, the extraordinary genius who saved the world from fascism by breaking the Enigma code in World War II, and who, to Henry's delight, shared his 'gift' of appalling handwriting.

Henry fully expects to go to university, and plans, he says, to 'write books, make films and be on the television when I am grown up'.

He enjoys writing scripts and dreaming up plots, so who knows?

Certainly it is being recognised more and more that students with Asperger's have a lot to offer, and universities are giving more support than ever.

I worry about his immaturity - he seems younger than his age and is rather 'uncool' compared with his more streetwise peers - but he will get there in the end, and I think he could be very happy one day with a nice, extrovert and bossy wife, just the type of girl who already tends to take him under her wing at school.

I have never written about Henry's Asperger's before, but I've been stirred to do so by anger.

As a mother and a voter, I feel nothing but loathing and contempt for those cowardly, two-faced Labour MPs who signed up to this newspaper's campaign for Gary McKinnon, then, faced with pressure from their own party, caved in and voted to sacrifice him - and any other UK citizen the U.S. happens to take a dislike to - for their own craven ambitions.

One, Denis MacShane, even sneeringly challenged McKinnon's diagnosis.

What a useless, spineless bunch they are. How dare they expect our vote? Their contempt for the electorate, will, I believe, rebound on them in the next election, and their defeat will be richly deserved.

Believe me, I never thought I'd write that. My decent, hard-working grandfather was a lifelong member of the Labour Party.

One of my ancestors was Joseph Edwards, a prominent early socialist and editor of The Labour Annual.

As a local councillor, my grandfather dedicated the last part of his life to helping the poor, the elderly and the weak and he taught us to be proud of the Labour Party's heritage. God only knows what he would make of this nasty lot.

There's one thing I know for sure, I'd take my moral, clever, square-peg little boy over any number of them.


Top
 Profile  
 
Share this information
 Post subject: Re: I feel such contempt for the spineless MPs who betrayed Gary McKinnon...
Post Number:#2  PostPosted: Sat Aug 01, 2009 11:06 am 
Offline

Joined: 19 July 2008
Posts: 140
Gary McKinnon has lost his final extradition appeal. He will almost certainly be extradited, tried in a US court, and subject to at least 60 years in a high security jail.

This is absolutely disgusting and disgraceful. He is a victim of one-sided 'war on terror' legislation from the Bush Blair era. British justice is completely subservient to US foreign policy where British judges have to bow to the requests of American politicians. If any more proof is needed that the so called Special Relationship with the US is for real rather than in the imagination of conspiracy theorists and American haters, then this is it.


Top
 Profile  
 
Share this information
 Post subject: Re: I feel such contempt for the spineless MPs who betrayed Gary McKinnon...
Post Number:#3  PostPosted: Sat Aug 01, 2009 11:52 am 
Offline

Joined: 19 April 2008
Posts: 159
Location: South of Hampshire
Reading between the lines I get the message that if the British government refuses to co-operate with the US government, but instead prosecutes Gary McKinnon in Britain, then it will result in serious repercussions for Britain in the future. A friend who is more knowledgeable about international affairs than I am says that the whole situation is school playground style bullying where if a weaker kid (namely Britain in this instance) does not take orders from a big bully (namely the US in this instance) to do something he doesn't want to do, then he will get his face punched at breaktime. Call me cynical if you wish, but I think that the US is playing macho man and trying to frighten the rest of the world that if they dare to interfere with them, then they will incur the wrath of Uncle Sam in an American courtroom and an American jail.

Gary McKinnon hacked into the US government computers during 2001 and 2002, BEFORE the extradition treaty came into force in 2005. Unless anybody can point out a specific piece of UK LEGISLATION that states that computer hackers can be extradited, that was published BEFORE Gary McKinnon was caught, then imposing extradition is a dirty underhand tactic of the US government resulting in rough justice and a 'hidden extra' punishment. There are no reasons whatsoever for the British government to extradite Gary McKinnon to US to face their system of justice, because:

1. He is a British citizen who committed the crime in the UK.

2. There is already sufficient legislation enshrined in British law to prosecute and jail hackers for their crimes committed BOTH within Britain and abroad.

3. US law does not apply in Britain.

4. If extradition is imposed then the laws will need to be equal between all countries on a global basis before it is considered fair or acceptable. I believe the current situation is very one-sided as in the US can extradite British criminals but Britain cannot extradite American criminals. Countries having stronger rights to extradite than others effectively end up imposing whatever laws they want, and penalties for noncompliance, on a global basis.

If Gary McKinnon was destined for prosecution in a British court under the Computer Misuse Act 1990 with penalties imposed by the British government in accordance to those stated in the Act, then it would be a completely different story. To prosecute an individual for a crime by issuing a penalty that is not officially published is a very unjust thing to do.

I actually don't think AS comes into the case at all. I personally think that Gary McKinnon should face trial in Britain and I would oppose the extradition just as much if he were NT. Britain already has sufficient laws to deal with computer hackers.


Top
 Profile  
 
Share this information
 Post subject: Re: I feel such contempt for the spineless MPs who betrayed Gary McKinnon...
Post Number:#4  PostPosted: Mon Aug 03, 2009 8:50 pm 
Offline

Joined: 19 July 2008
Posts: 140
An article in today's Daily Mail.

Cabinet split after Peter Hain demands Gary McKinnon be tried in Britain

Peter Hain refused three times to back the Home Secretary Alan Johnson's decision that extradition should take place.

In a legal opinion obtained by the Daily Mail, Tim Owen, QC, and Julian Knowles, of Matrix Chambers, categorically state: 'The Extradition Act 2003 gives the English courts the primary responsibility - but, importantly, not the exclusive responsibility - for ensuring that . . . safeguards are maintained. This is because both the courts and the Home Secretary have a role to play in extradition.

'It is therefore plain that the Home Secretary has the power - and indeed the duty - to intervene in any extradition case even after the court process has ended if the evidence establishes that there is a real risk of a human rights breach should extradition proceed.

Lord Carlile, the Government's independent reviewer of anti-terror laws, said he was satisfied Mr Johnson did have the power to intervene.

The QC said placing Gary at the mercy of the U.S. courts would be 'disproportionate, unnecessary and unconscionable'.

Last Friday's High Court judgment actually made it plain that Gary could be prosecuted in the UK for his crimes by the Director of Public Prosecutions, if Mr Johnson halted extradition.


Top
 Profile  
 
Share this information
 Post subject: Re: I feel such contempt for the spineless MPs who betrayed Gary McKinnon...
Post Number:#5  PostPosted: Tue Aug 04, 2009 7:01 pm 
Offline

Joined: 19 April 2008
Posts: 159
Location: South of Hampshire
Some news articles

Hacker Gary McKinnon loses appeal against extradition to US - Guardian, 31st July 2009

Gary McKinnon should be extradited, court rules - Guardian, 31st July 2009

I might never see him again: Mother of Gary McKinnon pleads for mercy from Obama after hacker loses extradition fight - Daily Mail, 31st July 2009

Hacker mother appeals to Obama - BBC News, 31st July 2009

Gary McKinnon: mother makes appeal to Barack Obama - Telegraph, 31st July 2009

Gary McKinnon: timeline of the computer hacker's case - Telegraph, 31st July 2009

40 MPs in plea to Barack Obama over computer hacker Gary McKinnon - Telegraph, 1st August 2009

Mother of hacker Gary McKinnon pleads for President Obama’s help - Times, August 1st 2009

Government to insist Gary McKinnon serves sentence in the UK - Times, 2nd August 2009

Gary McKinnon could serve time in UK jail - Techradar, 3rd August 2009

Betrayal of a naive hacker: Why are our MPs doing nothing to help Asperger's victim Gary? - Daily Mail, 3rd August 2009

Betrayal of a naive hacker - the ins and outs of the extraordinary extradition battle for Gary McKinnon - Daily Mail, 3rd August 2009

Links

FreeGary.org.uk

Join the campaign to prevent Gary McKinnon's extradition to the U.S.

AS Hacker Could Face 70 Years In Jail - Wrongplanet


Top
 Profile  
 
Share this information
 Post subject: Re: I feel such contempt for the spineless MPs who betrayed Gary McKinnon...
Post Number:#6  PostPosted: Sat Sep 05, 2009 12:32 pm 
Offline

Joined: 19 April 2008
Posts: 159
Location: South of Hampshire
Half a million Americans throw their weight behind computer hacker Gary McKinnon

Daily Mail, 28th August 2009

A popular U.S. civil liberties group last night dramatically backed the case for computer hacker Gary McKinnon to face justice in the UK.

In a significant breakthrough for the Daily Mail's campaign of behalf of the 43-year-old Asperger's sufferer, the American Civil Liberties Union described his plight as 'tragic'.

In a letter to Foreign Secretary David Miliband, the group - which has more than half a million members - said Mr McKinnon was facing removal to the U.S. under an Extradition Act which is 'lopsided' and 'unfair' to Britain.

The ACLU wants him to face prosecution for hacking into 97 NASA and Pentagon computers - offences committed while he was searching for proof of the existence of alien life - in the UK in the 'interests of justice'. This process would automatically halt extradition.

The intervention came as the Tory justice spokesman attacked the 'crude and clumsy' Extradition Act, and demanded ministers ensure ' justice is done'.

The developments are a huge boost to Mr McKinnon, who experts have warned could commit suicide if his extradition to the U.S. is not halted by Home Secretary Alan Johnson.

Supporters pointed out that even huge numbers of Americans did not want the hacker to be punished in the U.S. for crimes which were committed on British soil, from the bedroom of his North London flat.

In the letter, ACLU executive director Anthony Romero told Mr Miliband the 'unfair lopsided aspect' of the treaty meant that while Americans could only be extradited to the UK if 'probable cause' had been established, there was no equivalent provision for Britons facing extradition to the U.S.

The letter was released as UK civil rights group Liberty delivered a hamper to new U.S. ambassador Louis Susman containing letters from the ACLU and Liberty, as well as 'Don't let Gary go' paper planes.

Last night Liberty director Shami Chakrabarti said: 'The intervention of Liberty's sister, the American Civil Liberties Union, proves that Britain's Extradition Act is an international embarrassment.

'Vulnerable people like Gary McKinnon can be bundled off to other countries when they ought to be dealt with at home.

'If Parliament doesn't amend Britain's rotten Extradition Act to put discretion and common sense back into the system, other vulnerable sons and daughters are bound to suffer.'

Dominic Grieve QC, the Tory justice spokesman, said: 'The Gary McKinnon case throws into sharp relief the crude and clumsy extradition procedures Britain now has in place.

'The Extradition Act was introduced after 9/11, so that we could fast-track terrorist suspects to face trial abroad. The intention was reasonable. But it was never intended to operate in cases like this, diluting the safeguards protecting such a vulnerable man - and a British citizen at that.

'Ministers must make every effort to see justice done for Gary McKinnon.'

Last month, two High Court judges ruled that they could not stop the Government from sending Mr McKinnon to the U.S. But they said that if he is extradited 'his mental health will suffer and there are risks of worse, including suicide'.

Crucially, the judges also said the hacker could be prosecuted in London.

Mr Johnson insists he does not have the power to halt the extradition.

A Home Office spokesman said: 'The Government is satisfied that our extradition relations with the U.S. are balanced, fair and working well.'


Top
 Profile  
 
Share this information
Display posts from previous:  Sort by  
Post new topic Reply to topic  [ 6 posts ] 

All times are UTC


Who is online

Registered users: Google [Bot]


You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot post attachments in this forum

Search for:
Jump to:  
cron
This forum is powered by phpBB